| |
The prosecutor in Nanterre decided to open a preliminary inquiry after the statements of former Liliane Bettencourt compble indicating that sum of € 150 000 was delivered in cash to Eric Woerth to finance the presidential campaign of Nicolas Sarkozy. It's the least of things with regard to the seriousness of the charges.
Now, witness statements and the media frenzy are not a crime. Failure Case Julien Dray illustrates. Vilified by the press, found guilty mediation, the member of the Essonne ended up bleached after a year-long investigation of the financial police. There were many newspapers condemned then for defamation, including Médiapart .
myths, like that of Watergate, die hard. But the conditions of exercise of the press, including economic, have changed. In such cases, we have seen in recent years, investigative journalism is reduced in many cases to relate the testimony of a particular party of record, of any close case. Clearly, the investigation is often limited to transcribe the off or report information that is often covered by the confidentiality of investigations. Such a role is useful in a democracy and can allow certain evidence to be taken into account. It does not replace the investigation, the truth, that of the police.
While the police investigation, that the prosecution seeks to measure whether to give a criminal statute to these facts, it is good news. Where things get difficult is in the nature of the personalities involved: the President of the Republic, Minister of Labour and former budget minister, the first fortunes of France. The independence of the investigation will be fundamental.
Except that for several years, the government has questioned the independence of prosecutors. Unless we can wonder about the relationships between Nicolas Sarkozy and the Nanterre prosecutor Philippe Courroye.
remember that this judge was appointed to the post against the advice of the Superior Council of Magistracy, which had led the Union to denounce the judiciary "a lock from the right strategic positions" . He has since shown his zeal to the President who presents it as his "friend" . Thus, when Judge Isabelle Prevost-Deprez in July 2009 refused to rule on the request for damages in favor of Nicolas Sarkozy in the case of piracy of his bank accounts, which is Philip Courroye the frontline requesting a disciplinary sanction him. The initiative did not produce great results, except a letter from lawyers the President of the Republic asking him to clarify his links with the Nanterre prosecutor.
Does this mean that Philippe Courroye will not conduct the investigation properly? This would be a very serious charge against him who was the magistrate of the illegal financing of the RPR and arms trafficking to Angola. But suppose that the investigation leading to the shutdown because Eric Woerth, how will such a conclusion she received from opinion? By calling into question the independence of prosecutors, cultivating close relationships with a number of prosecutors, Nicolas Sarkozy has taken a position which can only be detrimental in such cases. A portion of the opinion always suspected of having obtained the rank because of his position and his personal relationships.
0 comments:
Post a Comment