Thursday, June 24, 2010

Ringing In Ears Causes More Condition_symptoms

Are the French troops in Afghanistan? Cheers

Friday, Brigadier Steve Coco died doing his duty. He became the 44th French soldier killed since the deployment of French troops in 2002.

By discovering this information, I wondered: Why did he die? What sense the presence of France in Afghanistan more than 8 years after the events that have triggered? To my shame, I realized that I had no clear answers. The presence of French troops on the ground is a fact recorded in the background of the news. By habit, I ended up not even think about it.

course I know why we sent troops in Afghanistan after 11 September it was down the Taliban regime which, by providing sanctuary to al-Qaeda had committed an act of war against our American ally. This intervention was made on a UN mandate in respect of international law.

Eight years later, the international context has changed, China has emerged as a great power, new actors have emerged in Brazil as an example, the Oslo agreements - already tired - have been finally buried the Iraq conflict seems to have fueled fundamentalism rather than the reverse, Russia has reaffirmed as a power with the war in Georgia ... Given these developments, what justifies the presence of French still close to Kabul?

As often happens in this case, It is tempting to look for hidden motives. Last February, at Science Po, Jean-Luc Melenchon , astride the horse of anti-American imperialism, we proposed an explanation based on access to oil resources. Turkmenistan, a country rich in oil, hopes to sell them without going through Russia. The road is blocked in Iran, there remain only solution for Afghanistan and Pakistan.



I do is little illusion about the real motivations of states in their military interventions. The outbreak and conduct of the war in Iraq have demonstrated that lying state could be used on a large scale. But we must avoid forcing the line: Afghanistan did nothing to the importance of Iraq in access to oil resources.

So the question remains, what justifies the French presence yet? And if the answer was simply that western intervention has failed and that our troops are bogged down? The Taliban have never been stronger, the conflict spread to the tribal areas of Pakistan destabilizing a nuclear power, the drug economy flourishes, the plan for the least corrupt of the President Karzai holds only thanks to foreign troops and to election fraud ... Hard not to talk about failure.

But if there is failure of military intervention, the question we must ask is one of disengagement. Obama has done and his response is to apply the strategy already implemented in Iraq:

- reinforce American troops in order to weaken the Taliban military position.
- Take advantage of this weakness to negotiate a part of rallying them to a central government that would manage as it sees fit, but the country would not attack U.S. interests directly.

In short, create conditions for a withdrawal of Western troops without victory nor defeat.

This strategy does work? What has applied to Iraq can be applied to Afghanistan? We'll see. But what is clear is that the French government has chosen to support the U.S. in this process.

Why not? But it deserves to be debated and that gives us indicators to measure whether the strategy of last resort has been successful or whether, instead, we definitely suffer a defeat.

It is clear that the Parti Socialiste and personalities such as Jean-Luc Melenchon or Dominique de Villepin, in their own way, tried to put the debate over the last 6 months. Without much success.

The Government remains of a great silence on the goals and strategy pursued. Why? Would he have so little confidence in the political establishment that he prefers to avoid the debate does not have to assume that he anticipates a failure? It should say in his defense that the results of surge U.S. remains limited and its theoretician and prime contractor, General McChrystal has just been relieved of duty for bullshit extramilitaire.

0 comments:

Post a Comment